Dexter is one of the biggest shows out there and a lot of that is thanks to the fact that it has some really great villains. Although I’d refrain from calling Dexter a “hero,” he certainly fits within that kind of archetype and what’s a good hero without a great villain. Thanks to great writing, Dexter was able to attract a lot of incredible talent to join its ranks. Not only is Michael C. Hall leading a strong ensemble, but the formula of the show allows a heavy hitter star to come in and challenge Dexter every season without having to commit to multiple seasons.
Now, we’re really seeing the extent of what that looks like with the star-studded cast of Dexter: Resurrection which features the likes of Peter Dinklage and Uma Thurman. With the new sequel series on the horizon and having recently ranked all of the Dexter seasons, now is a great time to rank all of the major Dexter villains. This only features major antagonists, so don’t expect to see The Skinner on here or antagonists that only appear in a few episodes.
11) Aaron Spencer
Captain Aaron Spencer isn’t as dreadful as some of the other villains on this list, but he’s one of the least interesting. The reveal that he’s the main villain of the season is held back for too long and there’s a missed opportunity to create more tension between him and Dexter within the workplace. Although there’s some interesting moments, such as during the blood drive, there probably could’ve been more overt conflict. Unlike Doakes who is suspicious of Dexter, having Spencer and Dexter be somewhat one in the same allows for a whole different dynamic.
On top of that, the reveal that Spencer is just doing all of this to get back at his ex-wife feels a bit underwhelming after all of the build up. It would’ve been better had they established Spencer having a history of total meltdowns prior to his divorce and lashing out in erratic ways. Instead, what we got feels over the top.
10) Oliver Saxon
Oliver Saxon is probably one of the most boring Dexter villains, despite how much of an impact he has on the show. He kills a lot of people, most notably Deb, but the performance is stiff, his backstory isn’t compelling, and there’s very little intrigue with him. Saxon also shares a lot of similarities with Brian Moser, but feels like the Great Value version of that kind of character. It seemed they tried to create some sort of spiritual brother for Dexter with Saxon that parallels his actual brother in many ways, but it falls flat.
For what was intended to be the final season of Dexter, Saxon was an underwhelming antagonist whose dramatic deeds greatly outweighed how interesting of a character he actually was.
9) The Doomsday Killer
The Doomsday Killer was a villain that had great potential, but ultimately, doesn’t quite get there. The scope and scale of his kills is more grand than anything else in the show and the fact that he puts Harrison in danger creates more personal stakes. However, all of the good stuff is undermined by a stupid twist along with a pretty unthreatening performance from Colin Hanks. The idea for something pretty cool was here and it has its moments, but ultimately, still feels like one of the weaker villains of the show.
8) Lila West
I honestly contemplated putting Lila on the list at all, but after recently rewatching Season 2, I was convinced she earned a spot. While not as high ranking as some of the other villains from the earlier seasons of the show, Lila was a compelling foil to Dexter. Despite being Dexter’s sponsor, Lila brings out a new side in Dexter – one that sees him betray Rita and take risks that he otherwise might not.
She honestly does care about Dexter, but her love causes her to lash out in violent ways and harm those dearest to Dexter. It creates a conflict that isn’t repeated across the rest of the show and is part of what makes Season 2 so unique and tense.
7) Jordan Chase
Jordan Chase is one of the most despicable Dexter villains as he’s a highly powerful, wealthy leader of a rape group. He’s also very unique as he’s a well-known motivational figure, which means he has security and expensive lawyers to keep him protected at all-times. That does make him a bit less interesting than some of the other people on this list as it means less opportunities for raw conflict and tension with Dexter. Although he avoids getting his hands dirty himself, he is a villain that everyone wants to see taken down. He’s also one of the only antagonists that Dexter himself doesn’t kill, as he gives Lumen the opportunity to do so as a form of revenge and closure.
6) Miguel Prado
While a well-written Dexter villain in his own right, Miguel is really elevated by Jimmy Smits’ incredible performance. He’s both charming and kind, but also has a short fuse that reveals a dark side that is waiting to be unleashed with Dexter’s code. At anytime, you feel that Miguel could boil over. His power as a high ranking public official also means that he can manipulate Dexter however he wants and abuse Dexter’s teachings for his own personal gain.
5) Kurt Caldwell
Kurt Caldwell is a massively underrated Dexter villain. Not only are his kills twisted, but the father/son theme that runs across Dexter: New Blood allow Caldwell to hurt Dexter on a massively personal level. When Dexter fails to remedy his broken relationship with Harrison, Caldwell steps in to be the kind of father that Harrison wants. He uses it to warp Harrison’s mind and for a minute, you think there’s a real chance that Kurt might actually turn Harrison completely against Dexter.
However, Kurt tries to kill Harrison himself as a way of getting even with Dexter for killing Matt Caldwell. This ends up bringing Dexter and Harrison closer together, prompting them to team up to kill Kurt. Unfortunately, Caldwell gets the last laugh as he plants some evidence in Angela Bishop’s mailbox that could implicate Dexter in Matt Caldwell’s murder.
4) Isaak Sirko
Isaak Sirko was another compelling Dexter villain, but his time on the show was cut short due to scheduling issues with actor Ray Stevenson. Sirko is a mobster that targets Dexter after he kills his secret lover. Unlike other Dexter villains who stab and bludgeon people, Sirko is a skilled marksman who proves how dangerous he is by taking down a bar of armed men all by himself. On top of that, Sirko – like Chase – is backed by powerful allies that make Dexter’s life hell. It’s a threat unlike Dexter has ever faced and even results in an unlikely team up.
3) James Doakes
James Doakes is one of Dexter’s most cunning foes, but not because he’s also a serial killer or force of evil. Instead, he’s trying to actively figure out what secrets Dexter hides. Ultimately, it’s a tragic tale that ends with Doakes being framed for Dexter’s crimes, destroying his legacy. Although there are some attempts to try and recreate that tension within Dexter’s workplace later in the show, Doakes’ energy is singular and unrivaled.
2) Ice Truck Killer
The Ice Truck Killer was the perfect villain to start the series with and there’s good reason they brought him back in Dexter: Original Sin. His murders leave an immediate impression on the audience as something we’ve never seen before in this genre, but the twist that he’s actually Dexter’s biological brother is nothing short of jaw-dropping. He’s the perfect person to interrogate Dexter’s code and morals, while also bringing out some of the humanity inside of him.
Despite Dexter trying to deny his emotions, he longs for human connection and he has to kill the only person he may actually be able to be fully himself with. It’s a really emotionally-charged conflict that shatters Dexter’s world forever.
1) Trinity Killer
There’s only one other person who leaves a mark on Dexter like the Ice Truck Killer, and that’s the Trinity Killer. John Lithgow utilizes his kind face and voice to make the Trinity Killer seem like a good soul, but he’s one of the most demented characters on the show. You never know when he’s going to explode or what version of him you’re going to get, constantly keeping the audience and Dexter himself on their toes.
The Trinity Killer is a big part of why Season 4 is one of the best seasons of Dexter as his mere presence creates suspense that is unlike anything else in the series. However, his most notable act is the fact that he kills Dexter’s wife, Rita, but Dexter doesn’t find out until after he has killed Trinity. To make matters even worse, Dexter’s infant son, Harrison, witnesses this act and lays in her blood, creating a parallel to Dexter’s own origins. Trinity’s final kill is a grizzly twist of fate and one that leaves Dexter and his son damaged forever, something that makes him Dexter’s most formidable foe.
The post Every Major Dexter Villain Ranked (Including Original Sin) appeared first on ComicBook.com.
